6 Reasons You Might NOT Want to Stay in Times Square
While it is often called the "Center of the Universe," there are several reasons to not stay in Times Square when visiting New York City. From persistent noise pollution and 24/7 neon-light brightness to the difficulty of hailing an Uber amidst heavy traffic, the heart of the Theater District can be overwhelming for many travelers. This Westgate Resorts guide explores why savvy visitors are opting for quieter, more authentic neighborhoods—like the historic Tudor City area near Westgate Grand Central—to enjoy premium dining, local charm, and better accessibility without the tourist traps of Midtown Manhattan.
| Feature | Times Square | Midtown East (Grand Central) | Lower Manhattan |
|---|---|---|---|
| Atmosphere | High energy, 24/7 crowds | Professional, historic, & quiet | Trendy, cobblestone streets |
| Noise & Light | Significant; constant neon glow | Low; residential feel | Moderate; neighborhood vibes |
| Dining Scene | Major global chains & tourist cafes | Upscale steakhouses & local bistros | Artisan cafes & "foodie" hotspots |
| Transport | Congested; hard to get rideshares and/or taxis | Excellent; hub for trains/subways | Good; walkable but limited hubs |
Why Times Square Might Not Be the Best Place to Stay
So, you’re planning your big trip to the Big Apple. You’ve got your Broadway tickets booked, your walking shoes broken in, and a list of things to do in NYC that’s three pages long. Naturally, your first instinct might be to look for a hotel right in the middle of the "Center of the Universe"—Times Square. It’s iconic, it’s neon, and it’s where the ball drops, right?
But here’s a little local secret: while Times Square is a must-see for a photo op, it isn't always the best place to rest your head. If you’re looking for a more authentic, manageable, and charming experience, there are so many better options. When you explore reasons to stay in Tudor City, for instance, you’ll find a serene, historic enclave that feels worlds away from the chaos while remaining just a short walk from the action.
Times Square vs. Other NYC Neighborhoods
Whether you’re crafting detailed New York City itineraries for a romantic getaway or a family adventure, where you stay sets the tone for your entire trip. Before you hit "reserve" on that Theater District high-rise, let’s look at why you might want to broaden your horizons and choose a neighborhood with a bit more soul—and a lot more sleep.
1. The Constant Hum of Noise Pollution
New York is famously the "City That Never Sleeps," but in Times Square, that’s a literal warning, not just a catchy slogan. Between 42nd and 47th Streets, the soundscape is a relentless symphony of honking yellow taxis, sirens, delivery trucks, and the chatter of thousands of pedestrians.
Even with modern soundproofing, the vibration of the city can seep into your room. If you value a quiet night’s rest or need to jump on a business call without the sound of a street performer’s drum kit in the background, the "Bowtie" might be a bit much.
2. The Unrelenting Glow of the Lights
There’s no denying that the giant LED billboards are a marvel of modern technology. However, when those lights are powerful enough to be seen from space, they’re also powerful enough to pierce through even the thickest hotel blackout curtains.
Staying in Times Square means living in a perpetual state of daylight. If your internal clock is sensitive to light pollution, or if you simply want to wake up to a natural sunrise over the East River instead of a three-story advertisement for a soda brand, you’ll find the soft, tree-lined streets of the Midtown East area much more refreshing.
3. The Transport Trap: Hailing a Ride is a Challenge
You might think staying in the center of it all makes getting around easier, but the opposite is often true. Because pedestrian plazas have restricted vehicle traffic, finding a legal spot for an Uber or Lyft to pull over is a logistical nightmare. During peak theater hours, traffic on the surrounding avenues grinds to a halt.
You’ll often find yourself waiting 20 minutes for a car that is stuck just two blocks away. Conversely, staying somewhere like Westgate New York Grand Central gives you the best of both worlds: easy street access for taxis and a five-minute walk to Grand Central Terminal, the city's premier transit hub.
RELATED ARTICLES:
The 12 Best Romantic Restaurants in NYC
10 Historical Landmarks in NYC You Have to See at Least Once
The Ultimate Guide to Tudor City Manhattan
First-Timer's Fear? Demystifying NYC's Subway System
4. A Sea of Chain Restaurants
One of the best parts of visiting New York is the world-class culinary scene. Unfortunately, the real estate in Times Square is so expensive that only massive national chains can afford the rent. Do you really want to travel all the way to Manhattan to eat at the same themed restaurants you have back home?
To find the authentic "mom and pop" delis, hidden speakeasies, and Michelin-starred sushi dens, you have to head slightly east or south. In neighborhoods like Tudor City, the dining is local, original, and far more reflective of the real New York.
5. The "Tourist Buffer" and Pedestrian Gridlock
Navigating the sidewalks in Times Square is less of a walk and more of a contact sport. Between the slow-moving tour groups, people stopping mid-sidewalk for selfies, and street performers, a simple two-block walk can take 15 minutes. When you stay in a residential-leaning neighborhood like Tudor City, you get a "tourist buffer."
You can visit the sights on your own terms and then retreat to a quiet, elevated enclave where the only people on the sidewalk are locals walking their dogs.
6. Value for Your Square Footage
In the heart of the Theater District, you’re paying a massive premium for the zip code. This often results in "micro-rooms" where you can barely fit your suitcase. By moving just a few avenues over toward the Grand Central area, your dollar stretches much further.
You can find historic hotels with actual character, higher ceilings, and even balconies—a true rarity in Manhattan. Why settle for a cramped box when you can have a spacious home base in a neighborhood with private parks and Gothic Revival architecture?
Why Tudor City is the Ultimate NYC Home Base
If you’re looking to avoid the pitfalls of the neon jungle, let us introduce you to Tudor City. Perched on a hill overlooking 42nd Street and the United Nations, this "city within a city" was designed in the 1920s to be a quiet sanctuary for Midtown workers. Today, it remains one of Manhattan’s best-kept secrets.
When you stay at Westgate New York Grand Central, you are positioned in this historic district. You get the iconic views of the Chrysler Building and the ease of being near the Chrysler Building and Grand Central Terminal, but you also get the peace of Tudor City Greens, two beautifully landscaped private parks that offer a tranquil escape from the pavement. It’s the perfect spot for travelers who want to feel like a "New Yorker" rather than a "tourist."
Neighborhood Guide: Where to Stay in NYC
Finding the right home base is key to a successful trip. Here is a condensed guide to the city’s top neighborhoods for every type of traveler:
-
Tudor City / Midtown East: Best for families and business travelers. This quiet, historic sanctuary offers Gothic architecture and private parks just steps from Grand Central Terminal.
-
Upper West Side: Best for families and culture seekers. Enjoy a relaxed, residential vibe nestled between Central Park and the American Museum of Natural History.
-
Greenwich Village: Best for couples and foodies. Explore iconic cobblestone streets, jazz clubs, and cozy brownstone-lined blocks.
-
Financial District: Best for value seekers and history buffs. Find great hotel deals near the 9/11 Memorial and the Statue of Liberty ferries.
-
Chelsea: Best for art lovers and solo travelers. Home to the High Line, hundreds of art galleries, and the famous Chelsea Market.
-
Williamsburg, Brooklyn: Best for trendsetters. A vibrant hub for nightlife and boutique shopping with the best skyline views in the city.
Discover the Real New York Beyond Times Square
New York City is a kaleidoscope of experiences, and while Times Square is a bright piece of the puzzle, it’s only one part of the picture. By choosing a neighborhood with more character, you trade neon gridlock for historic charm and a peaceful night’s sleep.
When you aren’t out exploring, Midtown East offers some of the best things to do alone in NYC, from getting lost in the New York Public Library to enjoying a quiet coffee in Tudor City Greens.
The area also boasts some of the best rooftop restaurants in NYC, like Ophelia, where you can enjoy skyline views without the crowds. Plus, staying near Grand Central puts you steps away from many free things to do in NYC, such as visiting the terminal’s whispering galleries.
So, with so much to see and do in NYC, who’s ready to experience the Big Apple like a true New Yorker? For more guides to exploring New York City and other destinations around the U.S., read more on the Westgate Travel Blog.
RELATED ARTICLE:
At Westgate Resorts, when you Check-In, there’s a LOT to Check-Out! Your vacation awaits! Start planning your next vacation today or talk with a vacation planner at 888-852-2959 or 407-355-2690.
* Westgate Resorts is in no way affiliated with the attractions featured in this article. Items or places listed are current as of the publishing date of this article. Please call or visit the respective website for the most up-to-date offerings and details.
When You Check-in, There's a Lot to Check Out
Sign up for our newsletter and check-in to great offers, secret stuff, and special events.